great thats an awsome idea you can go play wow or guild wars or something like that, the point of this game is to be open world with open pvp like real life, there would be 0 wars over resources or dungeons, wich are core features of the game, who in their right mind would run a dungeon with pvp on while some guy with pvp off can just wait around till he gets low hp and change his mind about pvp in the moment...I know. I think most of us already agree that PvP should be consensual.
i will not come back to this post and for the sake of sanity i will assume this was nothing but a troll post.
if it was not, its sad that after so many explanations you fail to see the point and you think this is all about choices... (i wonder if you would petition to remove stuns in wow because they remove the choices from the gameplay of the people that get stuned lel...)